If you’re struggling with soy allergies or food allergies in general, finding great alternatives for traditional ingredients can be tough, but it can be done! Here are our favorite soy free cooking products that we use in our kitchen
If you have have soy allergies, you know how hard it can be to avoid it! Soy products and soybean oil are in just about everything these days since it’s so cheap to produce and readily available. But there are some great products out there that are soy free if you have soy allergies! Today I’ll share some of our favorite soy free cooking staples.
Several of us have soy allergies in my house: my daughter, my son, and I are all allergic to soy (and possibly my husband, the verdict is out still on him). It’s not a severe allergy or anything, but enough to make us miserable! My daughter gets eczema on her hands like I do when we have soy, and it gets pretty bad.
Years ago I was having nagging health problems like dry patches and itchy skin, dark circles under my eyes, and sinus congestion. I had gone gluten free for a while to see if that helped, and it helped a little bit but none of these things went away completely until I cut out soy and a few other things I didn’t realize I was allergic to at the time (yeast and eggs).
While we still have a few things with a little bit of soy in the house (sometimes our store bought bread has soybean oil in it), I really try to avoid soy in everything we eat. I can have little bits of it here and there, but can’t have very much of it or regularly or my eczema flares up badly.
Even though my kids aren’t gluten free, everything I mention below is also gluten free, as well as dairy free since I’m also allergic to dairy. These products are often more expensive than their soy-full counterparts, but staying healthy and itch free is always worth the extra cost.
And just a side note: we’ve gotten comments before on social media and on the blog about how our food choices are unhealthy/not-as-good-as-mine/etc from health food nazis who feel the constant need to criticize. This post is for helping people who have food allergies, not so people can judge our food choices. Negative comments will be deleted to keep this positive for people.
Soy Sauce Alternatives
I love cooking asian cuisine and my family loves it too! Whether it’s sushi or stir fry, we all adore asian food of all kinds. Over the years, I found that coconut aminos work great as a substitute for soy sauce, and the coconut amino teriyaki sauce from Coconut Secret is really good, too. We add them both to stir fry, sushi, noodles, and more.
When we go to our favorite sushi place, I carry a little container of coconut aminos with me to dip my sushi in. So good! Coconut aminos are naturally a bit sweeter and less salty than soy sauce, and it has a wonderful flavor to me.
Another thing we love to add to asian recipes is fish sauce and toasted sesame oil (not pictured). Fish sauce has a strong taste and is salty, but it adds an awesome flavor dimension to asian food, as does sesame oil. Sesame oil has a low smoke point, so I don’t add it to the pan as it’s heating or it easily gets burned, but I add it soon after I begin cooking the other ingredients.
If you can’t have coconut aminos due to coconut allergies (or something else), Ocean’s Halo makes a soy-free soy sauce that’s also not made with coconut. I haven’t tried this brand yet so I’m not sure how it tastes.
Shortening and Margarine Alternatives
One of the things a lot of people miss with cutting out soy or making their kitchen a bit healthier is good pie crusts from cutting out traditional shortening made with hydrogenated vegetable oil (lots of soybean oil). Even if you don’t have soy allergies, regular shortening is a good thing to remove from your diet!
While coconut oil could be used as a sub for shortening, it’s not very stable for cooking since it has such a low melting point. Palm oil shortening works really well for making flaky pie crusts and soft cookies. The brand we use (Spectrum) is sustainably sourced, organic, and non-GMO.
Since we can’t have dairy, we used to use margarine a lot before we started eating healthier and cutting out soy years ago. It took a while before stores in our town started carrying soy-free margarine, but we found the Earth Balance Soy Free that our local Walmart stocks. It’s non-GMO and vegan, so no dairy, and it’s delicious!
This bakes okay, but like coconut oil it melts quickly so we use mostly palm shortening instead of the Earth Balance Soy Free in baking and frostings. They also make sticks of the Earth Balance Soy Free but we usually buy the small tubs.
Other soy free margarine/butter alternatives:
- Melt Organic plant butter
- Miyokos’ cultured butter (made with cashews). Update: Miyoko’s now has an oat milk cultured butter
- Country Crock Plant Butter Sticks (the sticks do not have soybean oil but the tubs do have soybean oil)
- Earth Balance Soy Free margarine
- Flora plant butter
Non-Dairy Creamer Alternatives
There are a ton of options out there these days for coffee creamers, like almond milk creamers and coconut milk creamers. Plain almondmilk and coconut cream work great as sugar free creamers in coffee (and I use them all the time), but it’s nice to have a powdered creamer option for traveling that is also dairy and soy free.
I’m not sure of too many other non-dairy and soy free powdered creamer brands out there, but I did find the Simple Truth coconut creamer and it has very little sugar in it and I love using it (it mixes the best when beverages are hot). They have single serve packets for travel or they have a bigger canister as well. I’ve used this before in homemade cocoa mix and homemade cappuccino mix and it’s great!
I’ve also been using the Nut Pods for my own coffee, while my kids use the So Delicious, Silk coconut, or Natural Bliss coconut creamer for their decaf coffees.
Peanut Butter and Chocolate Chip Alternatives
So finding a soy free nut butter and chocolate alternative these days isn’t as hard as it used to be, but I wanted to mention these anyway. Some nut butters have hydrogenated soybean oils in them, and some chocolate chips have soy in them, too.
We regularly use SunButter, which is soy free, and the Enjoy Life chocolate products since they are top 8 allergen free. We used to use Ghiradelli semisweet chocolate chips, but they changed their recipe and started using dairy in them, so we avoid them now.
The Nestle Simply Delicious chocolate chips are one of our new favorites, and we like them better than many other chocolate chip brands we’ve found so far, including Enjoy Life!
Soy free and egg free mayo options
If you have egg allergies AND soy allergies, finding a good mayo can be hard since a lot of vegan mayos still use soybean oil.
Here are some good soy free vegan mayo brands that we’ve tried. You can check out photos of the ingredient labels in our Instagram post):
- Good & Gather vegan mayo from Target, has a sweet-ish taste similar to miracle whip (but not as sweet). It’s pretty thick like regular mayo.
- Green Garden plant based mayo, we’ve been getting his at our Walmart and the one we currently use the most. It’s rather tart, it has more vinegar in it than normal mayo, but I don’t mind it. It is a little thin, I wish it was thicker. But this makes good homemade ranch dressing.
- The Hellman’s vegan mayo comes in a squeeze bottle and tastes a little like Miracle Whip with some sweetness to it.
- Sir Kensington’s vegan mayo, this one has good ratings on Amazon, but I didn’t like the taste of this one at all, I couldn’t put my finger on what I didn’t like about the taste. We barely used it.
- Just Mayo is my favorite and one we’ve used for a long time, but it’s hard to find for me. Our Walmart used to carry it but the company got weird with their products and distribution so it’s not available in my area and I can’t find it consistently when I go out of town.
- Follow Your Heart soy free veganaise is good (from what I remember) but is usually overpriced locally so I rarely buy it.
Here are a few egg free and soy free mayos we haven’t tried yet:
- Chosen Foods vegan mayo
- Only Plant Based vegan mayo
- Primal Kitchen vegan mayo
- Thrive Market non-GMO vegan mayo
- Great Guts mayo (made with bone broth for intestinal healing)
- Avonaise (made out of avocados and avocado oil, completely egg, soy, and corn free)
If you can have eggs, there are some great paleo brands of mayo without soybean oil in them, like Sir Kensington, Chosen Foods, and Primal Kitchen.
Or you can make your own mayo with this paleo recipe from Paleo Running Momma!
Other soy free products we use that aren’t pictured:
- Hampton Creek Just Ranch and other salad dressings: dairy and egg free and also very delicious! (update: the company stopped making salad dressings).
- Daiya non-dairy cheese and cream cheese, all soy free and top 8 allergen free
- Back to Nature crackers, some Ritz varieties we use are also soy free
- Silver Hills bread has no soybean oil (contains wheat), and Be Free makes gluten free bread products that are soy free
- Dave’s Killer Bread usually has no soybean oil in it
- Kashi Gluten Free frozen waffles are soy free
- Bumblebee very low sodium tuna, Ocean Naturals canned tuna, Wild Planet canned fish, and StarKist Tuna Creations BOLD are all soy free (many kinds of canned tuna are packed in vegetable broth containing soy, and some pouch tuna contains soy flour)
- Enjoy Life Foods packaged cookies are soy free and free of all top 8 allergens
Sarah Jane Parker is the founder, recipe creator, and photographer behind The Fit Cookie. She’s a food allergy mom and healthy living blogger based in Wyoming. Sarah is also an ACSM Certified Personal Trainer, ACE Certified Health Coach, Revolution Running certified running coach, and an ACE Certified Fitness Nutrition Specialist